Are the November outages a coordinated attack?

In one week, Microsoft’s email, the FAA’s air traffic network, Chase’s banking systems, United’s departures and a classified NSA network all went down. Many people online have joined the dots into one story: a cyberattack, a rogue AI, or a plan. A single explanation is satisfying. The record so far shows something more complicated and more worrying: separate failures with separate causes, most of them set off by a change to the system itself (a software fix, an equipment upgrade, a new release), at a time when real attackers are also active. Three recent attacks are confirmed, and none of them is an outage. Two were crimes for money: card-skimming code planted on 178 companies’ websites through Optimizely, and a hijacked page-speed script from DebugBear that drained $2.7 million from Polymarket users; the sites stayed up. The third, hacked supermarket and blood-bank fridges in Europe, France attributes to Iran’s Revolutionary Guards, a military motive. No U.S. outage this month has been attributed to an attack. This page lists every outage people are linking, what caused each one, which attacks were real, and which claims hold up.
These outages look less like an attack than like systems under repair. Microsoft traced its outage to a fix, the FAA to a router installed during an upgrade, Chase to a software release, the NSA to routine maintenance and Apple to an internal update. Security agencies are urging faster patching as newly found flaws pile up, and changes can break things. That is a sign of resilience: it would be far more worrying to see no updates as threats rise. No U.S. outage has been attributed to an attack.
What would change this rating ↓
outages.america2.newsAnalysis of Russian influence, information warfare and the networks behind them. Free; unsubscribe anytime.
New reporting from major outlets and official sources, listed as it appears. Our monitoring adds headlines from major outlets automatically. "Checked" means our software fetched the full report and confirmed it supports its headline. "Reviewed" means an editor checked it against its source. "Auto" items have not been checked yet. Tap a label for our note. None of this is an endorsement. Our assessment is the rating above.
The question is whether the outages are connected attacks. That will be settled by investigators (the FBI, CISA, the FAA and DOT, the NTSB) or by the companies’ own post-incident reports, not by timing.
AI is not causing these outages. It is changing the conditions that every large organization works under, and that is pushing them to change their systems faster.
The strongest thread running through this week is not an attacker. It is the pressure on every large organization to change its systems faster than usual, and to take them off the open internet where it can.
We include specialists who stick to what the evidence shows. None of them sees a coordinated attack. Several point to the same pressure: a flood of newly found security flaws is forcing faster software changes, and faster changes break things.
Newest first. “Stated cause” is what the operator or officials have said on the record; we note where it is still preliminary.
| Outage | What failed, and the stated cause | Attack? |
|---|---|---|
| Malicious code on 178 companies’ websites, via Optimizely (Nov. 16) | Attackers exploited a flaw in Optimizely’s web-testing service to add malicious JavaScript to customers’ sites, including the BBC, CNN, Zoom, HSBC and Equifax. The code tried to steal card details and swap crypto wallet addresses; the sites stayed up. Optimizely says it fixed the flaw and removed the code (SecurityWeek). | Yes A crime for money (card and crypto theft), not an outage; the sites stayed up. Nothing links it to the other failures. |
| Apple: iCloud sign-in, App Store, Apple Music and stores (Nov. 17) | Apple’s system status page listed the App Store, Apple Music and iCloud sign-in as “slow or unavailable” from about 11:45 a.m. ET, and AppleCare purchases on devices as unavailable (Apple). Its developer status page showed problems with App Store Connect and Xcode Cloud from about the same time (Apple Developer). Downdetector reports for Apple Pay and iCloud spiked around noon ET; Apple had not responded to requests for comment (USA Today). Store employees said their own systems were down too (PCMag). Apple said its systems were coming back “after an internal update caused some outages this morning,” and that the problems did not stem from a cyberattack. The outage also hit employee sign-in, internal tools and stores worldwide (Bloomberg). | No Apple: an internal update; Apple says it was not a cyberattack. |
| NSA’s internal classified network (Nov. 17) | NSA Net, which agency employees use to share classified information internally, went down, according to six people familiar with the matter; the agency staggered staff arrivals. The NSA did not comment at first (CNN). U.S. officials later told The Wall Street Journal the network was offline because of a software update, not a cyberattack (The Wall Street Journal, via ForexFactory). A U.S. official told CBS News the network suffered a “temporary degradation during scheduled routine maintenance,” and two officials said there was no evidence of a cyberattack (CBS News). A person familiar with the incident said the NSA was “simply updating its software to patch the system” and that the network would be offline only temporarily (Alex Ward, WSJ). The NSA later confirmed a “temporary degradation” of some networks during scheduled maintenance (Politico). | No Officials cite a software update; sources told CNN there was “no evidence of a cyberattack.” |
| Charles Schwab website (Nov. 17) | Customers reported login errors shortly after markets opened, about 9:55 a.m. ET, with more than 1,000 Downdetector reports by 10 a.m. Schwab had not confirmed an outage or given a cause (IBTimes). Schwab also had user-reported outages in August (Hindustan Times). | No cause given |
| Navy Federal Credit Union app (Nov. 16–17, overnight) | Members reported trouble with the app and website from about 11 p.m. ET; Navy Federal said its “technical team is actively working to resolve the issue.” American Express users separately reported login problems. Neither company tied the two together or gave a cause (IBTimes). Navy Federal also had a confirmed outage in August (Hindustan Times). | No cause given |
| Los Angeles County Superior Court civil reservation system (Nov. 17) | The court said its civil court reservation system was “currently unavailable due to vendor technical issues” (LA Superior Court). | None reported The court cites a vendor problem. |
| Gmail, Marriott, Apple iCloud, Toyota online services, National Weather Service data feed (Nov. 17) | Users reported problems on Downdetector, which counts user complaints, not confirmed failures. None of the companies had confirmed an outage or a cause at last check. The National Weather Service’s data feed for weather apps also had problems, with several hundred user reports (The Mirror). | Unconfirmed |
| Chase, and transfers at other banks (Nov. 16) | Chase customers had trouble with online banking and payments from about mid-morning until transactions were “posting normally” around 6:30 p.m. ET. An FBI official said it was traced to a software release Chase rolled out that morning. Other banks were hit only where Chase was a party to a transaction, and Chase said the problem was “not systemic” (Fox Business). | No Chase: “a technical issue, not cyber-related.” |
| United Airlines departures (Nov. 16) | A “widespread system outage” delayed some United departures for about an hour, starting shortly after 5 p.m. ET. United called it “a technology issue” and has not said more (Gizmodo). | No United: “no indication that this was a cybersecurity-related issue.” |
| Amtrak booking website (Nov. 13) | During the FAA ground stop, Amtrak’s website returned errors. Amtrak pointed to “increased demand for travel across our network” as stranded flyers looked for trains; it worked normally the next day (WJLA). | None reported A demand spike caused by the ground stop, by Amtrak’s account. |
| Amazon Web Services, US-East region (Nov. 15) | Sign-in, account signups and network connections failed for about three hours before AWS restored service. AWS did not attribute it to an attack (Cybersecurity News). | None reported |
| Verizon wireless 911 calls, Pennsylvania (Nov. 15) | A Verizon outage disrupted wireless 911 calls across several Northeastern and Central Pennsylvania counties for much of the day; texting still worked (WBRE/WYOU). No cause given. | No cause given |
| 911 service, Eugene, Ore. (Nov. 13) | A 911 outage hit about 250,000 residents. Police arrested a man on suspicion of stealing the copper wire that caused it (KEZI). | No Suspected wire theft, a local crime. |
| AT&T app and some network service (Nov. 13) | Users could not log in to the app and reported partial network outages; service was back by early afternoon (Android Authority). No cause given. | No cause given |
| National Weather Service radar (Nov. 13): did not happen | Reports of a nationwide weather-radar outage were wrong. The Weather Service said “there is no radar outage” and that outdated web pages had been circulating (Yahoo Weather). | No outage |
| FAA nationwide ground stop (Nov. 13) | The FAA stopped all U.S. departures from 3:54 to 8:15 p.m. ET after communications failed at air route traffic control centers. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said contractor L3Harris was replacing old copper lines with fiber at a remote site, and the router there began flooding the network. Officials are still working out whether it was contractor error or faulty equipment (Al Jazeera). The FBI has taken control of the router, CNN reported (Gizmodo). Our closed FAA Outage tracker has the full record. | No Duffy: “we don’t believe this was cyber at all.” |
| Microsoft 365: Outlook, Teams (Nov. 12–13) | Email and other Microsoft 365 services failed worldwide for about a day. Microsoft executive Charles Lamanna said a “latent defect” in a July fix for its network gateway servers was triggered when a surge in traffic hit at a time of reduced capacity; servers that came back were overwhelmed again, which slowed recovery (ABC News). | No Microsoft says it was not a cyberattack. |
| Apple iCloud, Find My and Apple sign-in (Nov. 10) | Apple confirmed outages in iCloud Mail, Calendar, Contacts, Photos and sign-in for several hours, then said all were resolved. No cause given (9to5Mac). | No cause given |
| Polymarket wallets drained via a page-speed script (Oct. 29) | Attackers hijacked the domain of DebugBear, a UK website-performance service, and replaced its page-speed script with code that drained crypto wallets. Polymarket halted trading for about an hour, said “one of our third party providers was compromised,” and promised to repay users (BleepingComputer). | Yes A crime for money (crypto theft) through a supplier’s script, not an outage. Unrelated to the November failures. |
| Supermarket and blood-bank fridges in Europe (Oct. 11 onward) | Hackers took over refrigeration controls at about 700 French supermarkets in October, then at more than 100 sites across Europe in November, including fridges at French blood banks. France’s foreign minister has blamed a cyber unit of Iran’s Revolutionary Guards; Belgium’s ministers disagree on whether the evidence is strong enough (NBC News). The equipment maker said most of the systems hit were older products that no longer received security updates (AP). | Yes The one real attack campaign on this list, in Europe. Nothing links it to the U.S. outages. |
Also mentioned online but not confirmed as outages: a Cox Internet outage (named in a widely shared Nov. 16 post; we found no report of it in news searches) and Gmail problems (user reports on Downdetector only; Google listed no disruption). We’ll add any that are confirmed.
What we could not check: the full post-incident findings. Microsoft, the FAA, Chase and United have given preliminary accounts; none has published a complete root-cause report, and the NSA has said nothing.
The most-shared claims about the outages, and what the record shows. Tap a row for the record; the link icon copies a direct link.
The companies and officials who have named causes describe internal failures: a latent bug, a router during an upgrade, a software release. DHS Secretary Mullin put his certainty that there was no cyberattack at “98 percent” (Newsweek), and an FBI official found no sign of malicious activity at Chase (Fox Business). The claim rests on timing: several failures in one week.
Where it came from: social-media posts after the ground stop, led by retired Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn (see “Who is amplifying it”).
Mullin relayed the idea on Fox News from an unnamed tech-industry source, saying it “kind of makes sense to me,” but offered no evidence (Newsweek). Microsoft said its outage was not “caused by AI tooling,” and the FAA’s administrator said there was “zero evidence of anything AI-related” in the ground stop. AI-driven hacking is real: the FBI warned on Nov. 13 about ARTEX, a tool that automates intrusions (The Record). But no investigator has tied it, or any AI, to these outages.
Where it came from: Mullin’s Nov. 16 Fox News interview; earlier questions from public figures (“Is it AI?”).
None of the causes named so far involves an AI tool: Microsoft traced its outage to a server fix, the FAA to a router installed during an upgrade, Chase to a software release and the NSA to routine maintenance. AI’s real role is indirect. It is finding software flaws faster, so organizations are patching faster, and more changes mean more failures (see why AI has made fixing software more urgent).
Where it came from: Nov. 17 replies on X saying AI being built into every system is “the problem.”
None of the stated causes involves the government or Project 2025: Microsoft traced its outage to a server fix, the FAA to a router installed during an upgrade, Chase to its own software release and the NSA to a software update. The Heritage Foundation’s Mandate for Leadership does propose splitting air traffic control from the FAA (pp. 632–634), a change it says would “require legislation,” and no such law has passed (Mandate for Leadership). It does not cover private companies such as Microsoft, Chase or United, and nothing in the record suggests any outage was caused on purpose to advance it (see our FAA Outage tracker).
Where it came from: a widely shared Nov. 17 post warning followers of Project 2025 that “the power grid is next” (17,594 likes), and earlier posts calling the ground stop the plan’s first step.
No Genesis Mission deadline falls in November 2026. The program, created by a Nov. 24, 2025 executive order, is a Department of Energy effort to build an AI platform for scientific research. The order sets deadlines of 60, 90, 120, 240 and 270 days, which fell between January and late August 2026 (Federal Register). The program concerns research computing at national laboratories, not the email, banking, airline or air-traffic systems that failed, and every stated cause this month is unrelated to it.
Where it came from: a Nov. 17 post by the commentator Drey (@thedreydossier) saying the outage timeline was “lining up with the Genesis Missions November deadlines” (1,626 likes, about 50,000 views; see amplifiers).
The administration is using the ground stop to argue for money: Duffy wants $50 billion to modernize the system (The Hill). That is a funding request, not privatization, and nothing in the record suggests any outage was caused on purpose. On Project 2025, see the row above.
Where it came from: X posts asking whether the ground stop was a “manufactured emergency to privatize our air traffic control system,” and a widely shared Nov. 17 post warning that under Project 2025 “the power grid is next.” Project 2025 says nothing about causing outages.
Each outage has a named, separate cause, and none of the operators reports missing funds, records or aircraft. The claim is phrased as a question (“some people are saying”), which lets it spread without a source.
Where it came from: a Nov. 16 post by former Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene.
DHS said FEMA would run “a routine, federally mandated test” of the Emergency Alert System at about 2:20 p.m. ET on Nov. 17, lasting about a minute on TV and radio, with “no action” required (DHS). Earlier in November, fake AI videos of President Trump announcing a “90-day blackout” circulated to sell crypto tokens (Snopes), and local outlets fielded questions tying that rumor to the test date (USA Today Network).
Where it came from: fake “90-day blackout” videos, and posts treating any nationwide alert as a signal of something bigger.
If the outages were one coordinated event, this week should stand out from the record. Measured against past years, it does not. One outage was very large; the rest were ordinary in size. Public interest is high, but no higher than after single outages in 2025. What is new is the story linking them.
Download this panel as an image to share →
Microsoft’s outage was the largest of 2026 so far, with 7.4 million reports (Mashable, citing Ookla). The 2025 Amazon Web Services outage drew more than twice as many, and nobody called it a coordinated attack (Ookla’s 2025 report, via Fonearena). Schwab’s Nov. 17 login trouble, by comparison, drew about 1,000 reports.
Weekly views of Downdetector’s Wikipedia article, a rough measure of public interest in outages (Wikimedia). This week ran about four times a typical week and ranks fifth of 202 weeks since January 2023. Single outages in 2024 and 2025 drew more.
Public figures with large audiences who have promoted attack, AI or cover-up theories about the outages without evidence, from across the political spectrum. Like counts as of Nov. 17. Listing a post here records what was said; it does not mean the person shares the other views on this list.
| Who | What they said | Reach |
|---|---|---|
| Michael Flynn, retired Army lieutenant general and former national security adviser | Nov. 16: the outages are “probably a cyber attack.” His list began with a Cox Internet outage that we could not find in any news report (X). | 13,159 likes |
| Marjorie Taylor Greene, former member of Congress | Nov. 16: “Is it AI?” (X, 13,874 likes, 916,000 views). Nov. 17: an outage “is a good time to delete info … to move money. Chaos keeps everyone distracted” (X). | 16,307 likes (Nov. 17 post) |
| Josh Hawley, U.S. senator (R-Mo.) | Nov. 17: if the outages are “all a coincidence, it’s like the greatest coincidence in the history of the world” (MSN). | Clip: 6,559 likes |
| @RabbiJeffx, a left-leaning X account | Nov. 17: “For those of you following along with Project 2025, the power grid is next” (X). | 17,594 likes |
| Drey (@thedreydossier), commentator with about 82,000 followers | Nov. 17: said the outage timeline was “lining up with the Genesis Missions November deadlines” (X). The executive order sets no deadline in November 2026 (see the claim row). The account later pointed to Energy Department upgrade plans for its own research computing, which do not cover the banks, airlines or email services that failed. | 1,626 likes, 50,000 views |
| Bark (@barkmeta), crypto influencer | Nov. 16: “First the banks. Then the internet. Then the power grid. Then the Great Reset…” (X). | 9,703 likes |
| Markwayne Mullin, Secretary of Homeland Security | Nov. 16, on Fox News: relayed an unnamed tech figure’s theory that “super intelligence” caused the outages, while saying he was 98 percent sure there was no cyberattack (Newsweek). | National TV |
| Mike Adams (“Health Ranger”), supplement seller and Natural News founder | Nov. 14: issued an “emergency alert” to followers calling the “multiple cascading failures” part of a pattern (X). | 12,405 likes |
| @ProudSocialist, an anonymous left-wing account | Nov. 14: “Did Trump and Duffy plan this whole thing to get a $50 billion” payout, quoting an unnamed pilot who called the ground stop “a big farce” (X). | 13,250 likes |
| Don Winslow, novelist | Nov. 16: tied a reported U.S. intelligence warning about an Iranian dirty-bomb plot to the outages: “Know when you are being fed and manipulated” (X). | 5,060 likes |
| Lara Logan, former CBS correspondent | Nov. 14: “cyber attacks can be used as cover to mask movement for a catastrophic event” (X). | 4,589 likes |
| Laura Loomer, activist | Nov. 16: listed the outages alongside Iranian threats: “We are not being told the truth about what is happening” (X). | 4,416 likes |